Friday, 24 July 2015

It’s an ill wind and all that.



Fathers’ Day and yet more loft sorting yielded some good reads which have taken up the slack caused by no painting (to speak of). I haven’t got a loft like the Tardis, but it does hide a multitude of sins, not least of which is my accumulation of books and such. I hesitate to describe it as a library because that implies some sort of order and method, which is the last impression you’d get if you penetrated the area. I’m similarly gifted in my reading discipline in that now, well separated from work and academia (don’t get the wrong impression!) I read books in just about any order I want. Luckily I am faddish so there is often a theme to my reading, but I am known on occasion to have several books of widely divergent subjects on the go at the same time. Except for novels: novels are read one at a time. 


So, in no particular order, I’ve highlighted a few books below from the battery of books I’ve read recently which are well worth a read and a couple which are maybe worth skipping if you haven’t got long to live. If you don’t like this list, I have others . . . .


Decision in Normandy - Carlo D’Este (Penguin; New Ed edition (29 April 2004); ISBN 10: 0141017619)



Quite a painful read about the command decisions in the Normandy Campaign and the relationship between Montgomery and the other Allied commanders. Not just Ike and Bradley, but Tedder, Conningham, Harris, Churchill and his own divisional and brigade commanders too. It’s an excellent book and should become a standard text for this campaign.


Well written and easy to read, it’s an unbiased and truly warts and all approach which also raises some interesting questions. I cleared the five hundred-odd pages in less than a week, even though it’s heavy in detail in places. My only winge is that it could have done with better maps, but that gets said about almost all military titles.



The Germans in Normandy -  Richard Hargreaves (Pen & Sword Military; 1st Edition edition (21 Sept. 2006); ISBN 10: 1844154475)



It’s useful and gives a reasonable view from the German perspective, but the dearth of German sources published in English probably exaggerates its worth. Hargreaves has an annoying habit of translating German words and phrases too literally: Widerstandsnest (WN) is translated as ‘nest of resistance’ rather than simply resistance nest or even strongpoint. However, it’s much better than Paul Carrel’s ‘Invasion – They’re Coming!’ which is pretty dire: outdated and badly translated.



Prelude to Waterloo Quatre Bras: The French Perspective – Andrew Field (Pen & Sword Military (14 July 2014); ISBN 10: 1783463848)


Waterloo: The French Perspective – Andrew Field (Pen & Sword Books Ltd (21 May 2012); ISBN 10: 1781590435)



I enjoyed both these books, but the Quatre Bras title more. As Field says, the French lost so there are nowhere nearly as many French sources as British. The Germans (all types!) and Dutch-Belgians are given a fair crack of the whip, though I’m sure Herr Hoffschroer would find something to moan about.


Both books give an interesting run down on the armies and commanders involved and, if you’re a fan of the 1815 campaign, both books are worth adding to your collection. However, the maps are good, so there must be something wrong somewhere.  


Now, that’s it for the military stuff so those who read nowt else can finish here. The rest of you, who have an imagination and who obviously appreciate good reading should continue. (Pause for smug smile . . . .)



Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell – Susanna Clarke (Bloomsbury Paperbacks; Tie-In edition (9 April 2015); ISBN 10: 1408856883)


You’ve seen it on the telly (or maybe you haven’t), but, as usual, the book is even better. A thousand or so pages of pseudo Dickensian prose with phoney footnotes about the renaissance of English magic. If you want a long, amusing and well written book, then this is one for you. Unfortunately, is contains some howlers and it’s obvious Ms Clarke isn’t steeped in the period, but it’s only pretend anyway.


 


The Graveyard Book – Neil Gaiman (Bloomsbury Publishing PLC; Children's edition (5 Oct. 2009); ISBN 10: 0747594805)



This is technically teenage fiction, but it’s a great read. Essentially, it’s about a boy who is brought up by a vampire and ghosts in a graveyard. He ended up in this situation because he escaped the murder of his parents, although the perpetrator intended to kill the whole family. How to educate the boy and keep him safe when you yourself have fairly limiting difficulties? Yes, it’s ridiculous, but it’s also excellent.



Neverwhere – Neil Gaiman (Headline Review (19 Sept. 2005); ISBN 10: 0755322800)



I was set off on a short Neil Gaiman fest by that last book and this one is a fantasy classic which has been adapted for TV and radio. A young man accidentally gets involved with the inhabitants of ‘London Below’, an alternative London whose population lead a parallel, semi-magical existence. The place throbs with intrigue and there might even be war. Mssrs Croup and Vandemar are possibly the best and most soulless villains in literature. Get it read!



Good Omens – Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett (Corgi (11 Dec. 2014); ISBN 10: 0552171891)


An angel and a demon rubbing shoulders with the hoy polloy? Even worse, they join forces to save humanity! I’m not the world’s biggest Terry Pratchett fan – I think he simply got into the habit of churning out pot boilers even though there are some excellent books in his (very long) canon. Nevertheless, this is a classic.


I make no apologies for the inclusion of three Neil Gaiman books. He’s not only a very good writer, but his ideas and imagination are exceptional. The references for the books are for editions you can buy nowadays.



Circumlocution

I’ve unashamedly swiped the idea of including whimsies and points of interest from a well respected and popular blogger. It’s not an original idea of mine at all, but it is a very good idea. Just thought I ought to mention that.

Those of you who actually read this stuff rather than just looking at the pictures (I know there are some who do) will maybe have noticed that I begin quite a few paragraphs/sentences with ‘so’. So, I want to point out that this isn’t the effect of the new fad of beginning every answer with ‘so’, which is becoming as insufferable as the seemingly unstoppable march of the upward inflection at the end of every sentence; it’s just me – done it forever. I fell into a despond the other night when I was watching a programme on the telly. I realised a succession of academics had adopted the ‘so’ habit, even quite sensible looking ones who were allowed to stay up late on a school night. Just shows how BBC2 has slipped over the years.

By the way, the leprosy appears to have had something of a shock accidentally administered by a week’s dosage of antibiotics, intended for something else. The upshot is that whatever was affecting my hands seems to have been given a thorough hammering by said medication and the latest in a long line of emollients. Could well be on the mend at last. Paint brushes this weekend then.

8 comments:

  1. Good selection of books none of which I've read.

    So, your mention of the upward inflection at the end of every sentence strikes a nerve. Like fingernails on a chalkboard to me. I wonder if this trend originated in Southern California and is an offshoot of "Valley speak?" Seems to be a generational affliction. To me, it is a sign the speaker has no confidence in what just popped out of his/her mouth. If you want me to take what you're saying with some seriousness, say it with confidence!

    Hopefully, you ARE on the mend.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Jonathan,

    I think that inflection actually started in Australia as it's been around for a while and I remember hearing it referred to as the 'antipodean inflection', but Vally Speak is fine by me: I still loathe it. The sad thing is how quickly these 'ticks' catch on nowadays >:O(

    Hands? I think it's a bad day when what I continually suggested to the medicos has come to pass. Seven years plus to qualify to be a doctor and I only for taught first aid. Remember when doctors listened?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'll certainly check out a couple of these books - thanks for this. Once again, I am caused to wonder what it was that kids' books were about before vampires and zombies and post-apocalypse teen-dating. A friend of mine who writes (duff) kids' novels to order from his publisher was recently asked to write a story about a schoolboy who, it seems, is a wizard, though looks like a normal schoolboy - now THERE's an original idea. Ker-ching.

    The Waterloo titles look interesting - there are some good Waterloo bargains just now. Some kind soul recently bought me Cornwell's Waterloo book. If you haven't seen it, I wouldn't bother. It has all the width of sources and sharp historical focus (did I say that?) you would expect. If you want to know what Napoleon was thinking at Waterloo, this is the book for you.

    Painting rack looks good - interesting - I had also wondered whether brandy corks were any use to you for painting - I was having a clearout and found a surprising number of the beggars...

    Cheers - Tony

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There's nothing wrong with a respectable accumulation of brandy corks, 'cept maybe the fire risk! Thanks for the offer, but I bought a baf of 100 of the 'plastic' sort a while ago (maybe in anticipation of my problems) and, at my rate of painting, they'll probebly see me out ;O)

      From memory, my generation was brought up on Biggles, Enid Blighton and the like and my kids used to read all sorts of stuff including Roald Dahl and even Anthony Hope and Rider Haggard. Glad I swerved the Cornwwell Waterloo book though ;O)

      Delete
  4. My eldest daughters driving me crazy at the moment, like your "So"m she keeps starting her sentences with "Basically", why? I don't know its just driving me mad, so....I thought I'd let you know??
    I've tried reading WWII books, but I'm sorry to say they bore me rigid, not sure why? I think its a Pike and Shott, musket thingy I've got going on?
    I do like the sound of the Neil Gaiman books though, I'll look them up, not the Pratchett one though, don't do him either. I'm reading zombie books at the moment.............yeah I know!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't think you'll be disappointed with Mr Gaiman, he's kept me amused for ages.

      I think WWII, as with any other period, is an acquired taste. Once you get beyond the bolood and guts crust though, I think it's fascinating. From a military point of view, there's not that much difference between, say Alamein and Blenheim. Same sort of characters, essentialy the same sort of problems, just faster communications really. Lace or armour plate?

      Delete
  5. I'll look up the Napoleonic books. Will be interesting to hear it from the French point if view for a change.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We could do with more books like these, but without the propaganda - if you know what/who I mean ;O)

      Delete